M1 takes money out of your accounts without telling you, and you probably shouldn't use it.
Like many people in 2018, I signed up for M1 Finance when I got my first job and wanted a fee-free way to start investing. They had lavish transfer bonuses and were app-driven while the old brokers charged $10 per transaction, had no controllable, let alone fractional auto-invest, and required you to go on the computer and use their website to edit anything.
I'd always felt an inkling in the back of my mind that since this was a startup, I couldn't be confident they would stick around forever like the old brokers, especially as they started to introduce more scammy upsells in the app. I never ended up investing a life-changing amount on the platform.
However, this year, during tax season, the website and app fully would not cooperate for over 2 days while I was trying to get my tax papers. I realized then what the cost of doing business with bad, scammy startups was. Schwab and Fidelity (let's not talk about Vanguard here) had upgraded to fee-free fees over the years from how competitve Robinhood became on the market, but they still had an old-school idea about customer service: 24/7 phone lines, and an actual live chat during business hours instead of that Zendesk asynchronous support system. I vowed to finally get off the platform and commit wholly to using Schwab and Fidelity. This is where the trouble started.
You may be thinking: Why post this? I ended up submitting a FINRA complaint about this and heard nothing back. Even then, FINRA's fines have been sub-$1m, which isn't enough to do any damage to a terrible company like this. Reddit has become overrun with AI bots. I'm not really sure where else to put this that'll influence people's decision making (both via AI crawlers to cite comparisons between brokers, and good old SEO), and more importantly, to get involved in a potential class action lawsuit. If any lawyers are reading this: Hi. I'm a real person, and I am very happy to be a named plaintiff if you have a case against M1 withholding money from customers' accounts.
What exactly happened? I withdrew all the money from my open accounts, and saw a balance of $1,433.80 that was not linked to any account, that I could not withdraw. I contacted support. What proceeded was 58 days of waiting for that money, and required constant follow ups from me. This creates several violations: FINRA 4511, 2010, 2050, and SEC 15c3-3.
I am posting an unedited version of the transcript with customer support to get this resolved.
I'd also like to note, M1 was already fined by FINRA for not profit sharing and offering no opt out on their SEC lending program. It's not something most users were privy to until 2023 when that FINRA violation came out. I believe I signed up for the platform in 2018, so I signed up before this was even part of the policy. You can read more about their recent changes to the program here. Note that Fidelity and Schwab do NOT sign you up for the SEC Lending Program automatically.
Conversation with M1
Started on June 28, 2026 at 11:33 AM Eastern Time (US & Canada) time EDT (GMT-0400)
--- June 28, 2026 ---
11:33 AM | Radhika Morabia: Ask something else
11:33 AM | Messenger: What can I help you with today?
11:33 AM | Messenger: For the best answer, please ask your question in full, including context like which product you are referring to.
11:33 AM | Messenger: However, do not include any sensitive information such as your social security number (ssn), account numbers, or password in your question.
11:34 AM | Radhika Morabia: All of my M1 accounts are closed. How is there still a net worth of $1,400? How do I withdraw it?
11:34 AM | Messenger: That $1,400 is most likely still in your M1 Invest account as cash (often from fractional shares being sold, or dividends/interest that posted after the account was closed), even if the account shows as closed. (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9332008-how-to-transfer-accounts-out-of-m1) Your net worth can also include external assets you added manually, so it may not match what’s actually available to withdraw. (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/14360984-how-to-use-the-m1-balance-sheet-and-cash-flow-tools)
To withdraw it, you’ll need to liquidate the account (this sells any remaining holdings and sends the full cash value to your linked bank):
- Log in → Move Money → One-Time Transfer
- Pick the M1 Invest account → pick your bank → enter the total value → Review → Confirm (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9331997-how-to-liquidate-an-m1-investment-account)
After you confirm, sales happen in the next trade window, then it typically takes about 3 to 5 business days for the funds to be available to withdraw to your bank. (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9332035-understanding-cash-transfer-timing-at-m1)
Sources:
How to liquidate an M1 investment account (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9331997-how-to-liquidate-an-m1-investment-account)
Understanding cash transfer timing at M1 (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9332035-understanding-cash-transfer-timing-at-m1)
How to transfer accounts out of M1? (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9332008-how-to-transfer-accounts-out-of-m1)
How to use the M1 Balance Sheet and Cash Flow Tools (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/14360984-how-to-use-the-m1-balance-sheet-and-cash-flow-tools)
11:34 AM | Messenger: Is that what you were looking for?
11:35 AM | Radhika Morabia: Move money is asking me for the account, but the From field is empty.
11:35 AM | Messenger: That usually means the app isn’t letting you pick the “From” account because it can’t find an active M1 Invest account to transfer from (even if you still see a net worth number). (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9331997-how-to-liquidate-an-m1-investment-account) (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9332029-how-to-create-transfers-in-your-m1-account)
Try this:
- Switch to the web version at https://m1.com and go to Move Money → One-Time Transfer to see if the account list loads there. (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9331972-troubleshooting-common-issues-on-m1)
- If it still won’t populate, update the app, then try again.
- If you’re on web, clear your browser cache and cookies, then reload Move Money.
Once the “From” account shows up, select your M1 Invest account, choose your bank as the destination, enter the total value, then Review and Confirm to liquidate.
Sources:
How to liquidate an M1 investment account (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9331997-how-to-liquidate-an-m1-investment-account)
How to create transfers in your M1 account (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9332029-how-to-create-transfers-in-your-m1-account)
Troubleshooting common issues on M1 (https://help.m1.com/en/articles/9331972-troubleshooting-common-issues-on-m1)
11:35 AM | Messenger: Did that answer your question?
11:35 AM | Radhika Morabia: No, send this to a human.
11:35 AM | Messenger: I understand your frustration, and I’m connecting you with a member of our M1 Client Success Team who can assist you further.
11:35 AM | Messenger: Which product do you need assistance with?
11:36 AM | Radhika Morabia: M1 Invest
11:36 AM | Messenger: To help us assist you faster, please provide:
- Your account details (if applicable).
- A clear description of your issue.
- Any relevant error messages or screenshots.
11:36 AM | Messenger: If you've already included all the necessary details, just type 'Done' to confirm.
11:36 AM | Radhika Morabia: I don't have any accounts left. They're all closed.
11:36 AM | Messenger: Thank you. We're connecting you to our Client Success team.
We'll respond to you within one business day, and you'll receive replies here.
We're available M-F between 9am-5pm ET.
11:36 AM | Radhika Morabia: Done
--- June 29, 2026 ---
02:20 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Thank you for contacting us regarding the remaining funds in your M1 account.
A residual balance of $1,433.80 remains due to certain positions still enrolled in the SEC Lending program.
Before we can proceed with sweeping the remaining funds, the positions must first be unenrolled from the SEC Lending program. Our Internal Team has already submitted the unenrollment request.
Once this process is completed, we’ll be able to submit a ticket to Apex to initiate the residual sweep. We will get back to you once we get an update.
Please note that it takes a few days to unenroll and another week to sweep out.
If you have any additional questions or concerns, please don't hesitate to contact us.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- July 6, 2026 ---
03:44 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Thanks for your continued patience.
Our internal team is still processing your unenrollment from the SEC Lending program. Please note that it takes a few business days to unenroll and about a week for the funds to sweep out. Once this is complete, we will submit a ticket to Apex to initiate the residual sweep and update you right away.
Your understanding is greatly appreciated.
Should you have any further questions or need additional assistance, please don’t hesitate to reach out.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- July 8, 2026 ---
03:16 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
We hope you are doing well.
Our internal team has confirmed that the fractional share liquidation will be completed within 1–3 business days.
Once the fractional shares have been liquidated, the automatic sweeps will be processed. We will continue to monitor your account and notify you once the sweep is complete.
If you have any additional questions or concerns, please don't hesitate to contact us.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- July 15, 2026 ---
04:51 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Thanks for your patience.
Your account still has a remaining balance. We are currently following up with our Internal Team to have the funds swept as soon as possible and will provide an update once the transfer has been completed.
We appreciate your patience and understanding as we resolve the issue.
Should you have any further questions or need additional assistance, please don’t hesitate to reach out.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- July 23, 2026 ---
08:32 AM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
We sincerely apologize for the delay and any frustration this has caused.
Our Internal Team is actively working on the remaining funds in your account. While we previously advised that the funds would be swept within 1–3 business days, the sweep has not yet been completed.
Please rest assured that we are closely monitoring the situation and will continue to follow up until the remaining funds have been successfully swept from the account.
We appreciate your patience and understanding, and we will keep you informed of any updates as they become available.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- July 24, 2026 ---
04:56 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Apologies for the delay in our response.
Our Internal Team has requested confirmation on whether you would like to liquidate the fractional shares in your account. Please let us know how you would like to proceed.
If you have any additional questions or concerns, please don't hesitate to contact us.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- July 28, 2026 ---
03:09 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
We hope you are doing well.
Our Internal Team has asked us to confirm whether you would like to liquidate the fractional shares remaining in your account. Please let us know your preference so we can proceed accordingly.
Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any further questions or concerns.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- July 31, 2026 ---
11:50 AM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Please confirm if you would like to liquidate the fractional shares remaining in your account.
Should you have any further questions or need additional assistance, please don’t hesitate to reach out.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
03:10 PM | Radhika Morabia: Yes, I would like to liquidate the fractional shares remaining in my account.
03:12 PM | Radhika Morabia: Can you confirm what balance is left and where it will go to? I don't see anything in my account now, but I know I had a balance of $1,433 that M1 was holding.
--- August 3, 2026 ---
03:23 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Thank you for confirming.
We can see that there is a remaining balance of $1,427.76 in your account, and these funds are to be transferred to your receiving account ending in 714.
Could you please confirm whether the receiving account ending in 714 is still open and able to accept incoming funds? This will help ensure the remaining balance is delivered successfully.
Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any further questions or concerns.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- August 5, 2026 ---
02:48 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Our Transfer Team has initiated the liquidation, and the transfer is expected to be processed during the next PM transfer window. We will keep you updated and notify you as soon as the transfer has been completed.
Thank you for your patience and understanding while we work to resolve this issue.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- August 12, 2026 ---
10:24 AM | Radhika Morabia: Hi, has the transfer been completed?
10:24 AM | Radhika Morabia: My M1 account still shows a net worth of $1457
10:24 AM | Radhika Morabia: This thread has been open for months. Can you please just withdraw my money? This is ridiculous.
10:44 AM | Radhika Morabia: If this amount is not released to my connected bank account within 5 business days, I will escalate this matter entirely to FINRA and the SEC with copies of this neglected ticket history.
--- August 13, 2026 ---
05:44 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
We understand your frustration with the delay and appreciate the importance of receiving these funds as soon as possible.
Please know that we are actively working to facilitate the transfer of the remaining funds in your account. The request has been escalated to the appropriate team for review and processing, and we are closely monitoring its progress.
While we cannot guarantee a specific completion date, we are making every effort to have the funds released as quickly as possible.
We value your patience and will continue to provide updates as soon as new information becomes available.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- August 19, 2026 ---
11:12 AM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Thanks for you continued patience.
We have received an update from our Internal Team confirming that they are still working on the PTD request. The funds are expected to be moved during the first half of next week. We will continue to monitor the request and provide updates as soon as they become available.
Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any further questions or concerns.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- August 25, 2026 ---
09:27 AM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
We hope you are doing well.
This confirms that the remaining funds from your account have been successfully transferred. The account ending in 950 now reflects a zero balance, indicating that all assets and funds have been transferred to your new firm.
We appreciate your patience and understanding throughout the process.
Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any further questions or concerns.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
09:27 AM | Messenger: Rate your conversation
--- August 29, 2026 ---
02:50 PM | Messenger: Help our team understand how they’re doing:
02:51 PM | Messenger: Let our team take a second look at this.
02:51 PM | Radhika Morabia: Took 3 months to resolve this. I ended up filing a FINRA complaint.
02:55 PM | Radhika Morabia: Can you confirm the internal name of the account the money was transferred to? I am unable to see which banks I have connected in M1.
--- August 31, 2026 ---
09:43 AM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
We understand your frustration with how long this took and appreciate your patience throughout the process.
Upon review, we can confirm that the funds were transferred to your brokerage account ending in 7714.
Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any further questions or concerns.
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- September 2, 2026 ---
03:33 PM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
We hope you are doing well.
Could you please confirm if you still require any further assistance?
If there’s anything else we can help with, please let us know!
Regards,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
--- September 4, 2026 ---
10:12 AM | Maria from M1: Hi Radhika,
Since we haven’t received a response from you, we’ll go ahead and close this conversation. Please don’t hesitate to reach out if you have any further questions.
The best way to reach us is by logging in and clicking “Help” in the lower left corner on Web or tap "Client Support" on Mobile (https://dashboard.m1.com/d/settings/).
Best,
Maria
Client Success, Associate
---
Exported from M1 on November 16, 2026 at 03:34 AM Eastern Time (US & Canada) time EST (GMT-0500)
-
If you would like to get in touch with me, send me an email at hi@[thisdomain].com.
- Previous: Goodbye Cursor. Hello Zed.